Italian flag
Opinions

The Value of Being Useless

4 Mins read

Wise voices remind us that a meaningful life begins with the ability to distinguish what truly matters from what is fleeting.

ITALY – True freedom doesn’t lie in chasing after everything, but in knowing how to simplify and choose — to let go of what is unnecessary in order to focus on what really counts. It means setting aside the superfluous to make room for the essential.

But no one gives us a list of what those essential things are. In reality, we often dedicate far more time to “non-essential” things than to those we’re told are fundamental. Years ago, a Swiss psychiatrist once said that mental health — whether preserved or regained — relies on just two basic elements: a place to live and a job. That’s it. Everything else, he argued, simply enriches a person’s life and contributes to well-being, which goes far beyond basic health.

And yet, looking at many young people today, it seems they not only lack the ability to distinguish between what matters and what doesn’t — but even struggle to meet the bare minimum of adult life: education, work, and training. It’s not just about distraction or laziness; the phenomenon known as NEET reveals something deeper and more troubling.

The acronym NEET refers to young people aged 16 to 29 who are Not in Education, Employment, or Training. This category has only recently begun to receive consistent attention from institutions and social researchers. The numbers are striking: globally, NEET rates range from 8% to 40%. In Italy, it exceeds 20% of the youth population. This isn’t a small, marginal group — it’s a significant portion of a generation, with serious economic, social, and cultural consequences.

From my clinical experience and direct contact with many of these cases, I notice a common thread: passive resistance. These young people appear either unwilling or unable to take initiative. They don’t respond to external motivation or educational prompts, leaving families stuck between frustration and despair.

After repeated, failed efforts, families often give up. These are no longer children to be raised, but young adults who reject correction, guidance, or structured plans. Meanwhile, time moves on, and their inertia becomes an emotional and financial burden on those who support them.

Beyond the “official” NEETs, there’s a wider, more ambiguous group. These are young people who technically have jobs or attend school, but do so with minimal effort or care. Some pour their energy into idealistic causes or side projects that seem more like forms of escapism than meaningful steps toward the future.

Then there are those who, despite working, are clearly unmotivated and dissatisfied. They avoid responsibilities whenever possible and skillfully exploit bureaucratic loopholes to skip work.

In the past, we might have labeled this phenomenon as social parasitism, borrowing the term from biology. What these individuals have in common is a lack of motivation and responsibility — a half-hearted engagement where outward actions (like working or studying) don’t reflect any real commitment.

It would be too simplistic to call them “sick.” And often, there is no clear cure. Some psychologists interpret this behavior as a mix of defensive or even aggressive coping mechanisms. On one hand, it’s a form of resistance to a society obsessed with consumption and productivity; on the other, it reflects a deeper anger — sometimes open, sometimes hidden behind ideology — aimed at a world of adults perceived as boring, uninspiring, and oppressive.

To see this only through an economic or social lens would be too narrow. At its root, the issue is existential: Why bother? What’s worth the effort? Many young people see society as lacking in meaning — unable to offer any compelling reason to engage.

Work seems unstable or unrewarding, education disconnected from real life, and adult life more threatening than appealing. In this vacuum of meaning, passivity becomes a defense mechanism — maybe even a quiet protest against a world that no longer persuades.

So what do we make of the sages’ advice to seek what’s essential? Perhaps today, the “essential” isn’t just about having a job or studying, but about rediscovering what gives life meaning, what fuels deep motivation.

Paradoxically, even activities that seem “useless” — artistic passions, personal exploration, time spent on non-productive interests — can be powerful, if they connect young people to their inner selves and to life itself.

Education, then, shouldn’t draw a sharp line between what’s useful and what isn’t. Instead, it should integrate both: teaching the discipline of study and work without stifling the need for freedom, creativity, and purpose.

The NEET phenomenon challenges us as a society: it’s not enough to demand that young people “fit in” — we must offer them a world they actually want to be part of. What’s essential isn’t simply doing something, but finding a reason to do it.

This is right and necessary. But looking at NEETs from a different perspective also reveals narcissistic traits. The individual becomes self-sufficient. Paradoxically, solitude and inertia evolve into a lifestyle — one that grants a sense of importance they can’t find in the real world.

In the end, the so-called “useless” things we do in life far outnumber the strictly “necessary” ones. And it’s often these very things — seemingly trivial, unproductive moments — that we remember fondly, the ones that bring us a quiet satisfaction.

Allowing ourselves, in moderation, to indulge in what’s “unnecessary” can help balance the hyperactive pace of modern life. It’s ironic: as life expectancy grows and we have more time, we live faster — as if life were shorter.

Maybe, when someone finally helps us understand that no one is truly irreplaceable, we’ll begin to see the value in simply being “useless.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *